The Question Beneath the Noise
By: Samuel Whitaker
From the fictional town of Cedar Valley, where characters from Quiet Echo continue to respond to real-world events.
All week long, voices have risen in accusation and defense. The headlines told us what was said, who shouted louder, and how the crowd responded. Yet beneath the noise lingers a question rarely asked: what kind of people are we becoming when we speak this way?
As a retired teacher, I’ve spent a lifetime listening to young voices rise in both argument and curiosity. That experience has taught me something: it is not the volume of the voice but the shape of the question that reveals wisdom.
Cedar Valley is small, but even here, echoes of the larger world reach us. Children repeat what they overhear. Neighbors trade stories with tones borrowed from national broadcasts. And slowly, without noticing, our language hardens. When words lose grace, our hearts follow.
The deeper question is not about which side “won” this week’s exchange, but what these contests of speech are doing to us as a people. If every debate becomes a battlefield, do we forget that speech was given not only for argument but for prayer, blessing, and truth-telling? If every voice aims to overpower, who listens for the quiet answer that might carry wisdom?
This column does not offer a solution so much as an invitation: What if we judged the health of our community not by how loud our arguments are, but by how well we listen? What if we asked not, “Who was right?” but, “Were we kind?”
At the end of the day, each of us holds sway over a small circle—our porch, our family table, our workplace. If we begin by asking better questions there, perhaps the nation might one day follow. Perhaps these are the musings of an old teacher, but I have learned that asking the right question often matters more than giving the right answer.
This editorial is part of the fictional Cedar Valley News series. While the people and town are fictional, the national events they reflect on are real.
It’s free, it’s fresh, and it’s waiting for you on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and all major platforms starting October 6. We’re launching Quiet Echo—A Cedar Valley News Podcast! Every day, you’ll hear a short editorial straight from the fictional newsroom of the Cedar Valley News. Join us in Cedar Valley—you’ll feel right at home.