How to Ask for a Review

The reader loved the book. The review never appeared. Not because they didn’t care. Because no one asked.

The signing went well. A woman stood at your table for ten minutes, telling you the book meant something to her. She described the chapter reaching her at exactly the right moment. She held the book against her chest and said, “Thank you for writing this.”

You shook her hand. You signed her copy. You watched her walk out the door.

You never asked her to leave a review.

She went home, placed the book on her nightstand, and meant to write something on Amazon. Life intervened. The groceries needed buying. The grandchildren called. The book stayed on the nightstand and the intention stayed in her head, growing quieter every day until it disappeared.

Her review — the honest, specific, human testimony of a reader who was moved — does not exist. Not because she refused. Because no one bridged the gap between her feeling and her action.

The bridge is the ask.

Why Authors Resist

Most authors would rather walk barefoot across a gravel parking lot than ask someone for a review. It feels like begging. It feels like reducing a sacred exchange — the reader’s private experience of the book — into a transaction.

It is neither. The review is not a favor to you. It is a service to the next reader — the stranger browsing Amazon at midnight, trying to decide whether your book is worth the risk. When you ask for a review, you are not asking for yourself. You are asking on behalf of the reader who has not found the book yet.

 

The Ask Itself

The ask is simple. It is direct. It is honest. And it is personal.

“If the book meant something to you, would you take a few minutes to leave an honest review on Amazon? It doesn’t need to be long — even two or three sentences help. Here’s the direct link.”

Three elements make this work.

First, the word “honest.” You are not asking for praise. You are asking for truth. This releases the reader from the pressure of writing something flattering and gives them permission to say what they actually felt. Paradoxically, this produces better reviews — because honest reviews are specific, and specific reviews are persuasive.

Second, the direct link. Do not tell someone to “find it on Amazon.” Find the book’s Amazon page yourself, copy the URL, and include it in your message. Every step you remove between the reader’s intention and the review doubles the chance it actually happens.

Third, the permission to be brief. “Two or three sentences” tells the reader this is not an essay assignment. The reviews carrying the most weight on Amazon are often the shortest — “Finished this in two days. Bought a second copy for my sister.” Fourteen words. More persuasive than a thousand-word analysis.

 

The Follow-Up

Most readers who say yes will forget. This is not disrespect. It is life.

Two weeks after the ask, send a brief follow-up. “Just a quick reminder — if you’ve had a chance to read the book, I’d love an honest review on Amazon. Here’s the link again.” The reader who meant to write the review and forgot will be grateful for the nudge. One follow-up. Not two. Not three. One. After the follow-up, the ask is complete.

Who to Ask

Start with the people who read the manuscript before publication. They already know the book. They have already formed an opinion. The ask is not a cold call — it is a continuation of a relationship already begun.

Next, your endorsers. If someone was willing to put their name on a blurb, they are willing to post the blurb as an Amazon review. Ask them. Most will say yes immediately.

Then, every reader who tells you the book mattered to them — at a signing, in an email, after a speaking event. The moment they tell you is the moment to ask. Not later. Not in a follow-up message. Right then, while the feeling is fresh and the connection is alive.

Do not ask anyone who has not read the book. Do not pay for reviews. One dishonest review destroys the credibility of every honest one surrounding it.

The woman at the signing loved your book. She would have written a review if you had asked. She was waiting for the bridge. Build it.

The Power of Authors by Evan and Lois Swensen explores what it means to write with purpose — and why the ask is not a transaction but an act of service to the reader who hasn’t found the book yet.

The Power of Authors is available from Amazon or your favorite bookseller: http://evanswensen.com. If you’d like an autographed copy, you can order it here: http://bit.ly/4pgmzjM.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Start Your Publishing Journey with Expert Guidance.
Unlock Exclusive Tips, Trends, and Opportunities to Bringing Your Book to Market.

About Us

Kindly contact us if you've written a book, if you're writing a book, if you're thinking about writing a book, we can help!

Social Media

Payment

Publication Consultants Publication Consultants

Copyright 2023 powered by Publication Consultants All Rights Reserved.