The Brew They Tried to Ban

Evan Swensen
August 13, 2025

If you’ve ever cradled a warm mug in the morning and felt civilization start to make sense, you might be surprised to learn coffee once had a reputation closer to a villain than a breakfast hero. This isn’t just any quirky beverage tale—it’s fun trivia, grounded in real history, and it might make you smile the next time you sip.

Coffee arrived in Europe in the 1600s, carried from the Ottoman Empire into bustling ports like Venice. Merchants brought not only the beans but also brewing traditions, and before long, coffeehouses sprang up in city after city. These weren’t quiet spots to check email. They were alive with conversation, music, chess matches, and political debates. Ideas flowed as freely as the dark liquid in the cups, and that was part of the problem.

Authorities noticed coffeehouses attracted thinkers, reformers, and the occasional rabble-rouser. England’s King Charles II saw them as breeding grounds for dissent. In 1675, he issued a proclamation to close them, claiming they spread “false news.” Public pushback was so strong he rescinded the order within a week—proof even then that people valued their coffee as much as their free speech.

The controversy wasn’t limited to England. In Mecca during the 1500s, coffee faced an outright ban. Religious leaders feared it might encourage radical thinking, as men gathered in cafés late into the night. Ottoman Sultan Murad IV later went so far as to make drinking coffee a capital offense, though enforcement proved tricky. Coffee drinkers proved far more committed than coffee policemen.

Even the papacy got involved. When coffee reached Rome, some clergy called it the “bitter invention of Satan” and wanted it banned. But Pope Clement VIII, after tasting it, declared it so delicious it would be a shame to leave it to non-Christians. His approval helped spread coffee through Catholic Europe, possibly accelerating its role in the Enlightenment.

The idea of coffeehouses as “penny universities” came from England, where a cup cost one penny and offered entry into a room full of knowledge. You could sit beside merchants, philosophers, sailors, or poets. Deals were struck, plays were planned, and newspapers were read aloud. It was an open exchange of information in a time when information often belonged only to the elite.

Not everyone liked this democratization of ideas. Some governments and religious authorities feared any space where ordinary people could freely discuss politics, commerce, or philosophy. Others worried coffeehouses would distract men from work, drain wages, and lead to social disorder. Yet, despite repeated bans and moral scoldings, the drink kept finding its way into cups.

One reason coffee spread so quickly was its difference from alcohol. Beer and wine were often safer than water in cities, but they dulled the mind. Coffee, by contrast, sharpened thought, kept workers alert, and fueled creativity. Writers like Voltaire and Balzac reportedly consumed extraordinary amounts, crediting coffee with helping them meet deadlines and dream up ideas. Voltaire was said to drink as many as fifty cups a day—possibly a French exaggeration, but still a testament to his devotion.

Today, the coffeehouse culture that once alarmed kings and sultans feels normal. We meet friends in cafés, work on laptops in corner booths, and linger over cappuccinos without fear of royal edicts. Yet the roots of this simple pleasure run through centuries of suspicion, resistance, and, ultimately, acceptance.

Coffee’s history reminds us a drink can be more than a drink—it can be a spark. In its earliest European days, coffee was accused of inspiring dangerous conversations, fostering intellectual rebellion, and stirring political unrest. In other words, it brought people together. And maybe that’s what made it so powerful—and so feared.

So the next time you order a latte or settle into a quiet corner with a black brew, consider the strange journey your cup has taken. Somewhere in its past are street protests in London, theological debates in Rome, and shadowy meetings in Istanbul. Somewhere in its aroma is the memory of ideas whispered across small tables, too bold for the times.

Your coffee might just be the most rebellious thing in your kitchen.

Health Note: Coffee isn’t harmless. Too much can cause insomnia, anxiety, rapid heartbeat, digestive issues, and may weaken bones. Those with heart problems or who are pregnant should limit or avoid it entirely.

Help Us Spread the Word

If this trivia made you smile or taught you something new, why not pass it on? Readers love curious facts—and writers do too. Here’s how you can help:

Share the post on Facebook or in a book club group
Forward it to someone who enjoys little-known stories
Talk about it at your next book club meeting

Invite others to join us here:
www.publicationconsultants.com/newsletter

We’re growing a book-loving community one great story at a time. Your share might be why someone falls back in love with reading—or dares to start writing.