Not a Vengeful Family

Cedar Valley News
Fictorial Number 468 · November 17, 2026
Not a Vengeful Family
By George Khan

A man comes into the Deli Kitchen most Saturdays in a running shirt, still breathing hard, and orders a turkey on rye he says he has earned. I thought of him this week when I read about Victor Birch.

Victor Birch carried the mail in Mobile, Alabama, and helped start a running club there called the Blue Bell Bombers. One early morning in September 2022, on the Industrial Canal bridge, a car driven by a young man named Aubrey Aaron Pate crashed and killed him.

In August, a jury found Pate guilty of reckless manslaughter. Prosecutors had alleged he was drinking and using marijuana. The judge, Vicki Davis, did not go easy at sentencing. “For such a young man,” she told him, “your driving record is horrible.”

The prosecutor, Ashley Rich, had planned to ask for 20 years. Then she talked with Victor’s family. In court she asked instead for the sentence Pate would have received under a plea deal: 20 years, with all but five suspended. “I feel it’s very necessary to extend grace,” she said.

Victor’s brother, Erich Birch, is a lawyer in Texas. He stood and asked the judge for the low end of the range.

“We are not a vengeful family,” he said. “Any punishment you receive won’t make us feel better.”

He did not pretend. “We do know he made bad decisions, and his bad decisions cost Victor’s life.” But he said something about his brother, too. Victor, he said, was “all about mercy.” He “really had nothing but good thoughts and love for other people.”

The judge sentenced Pate to 15 years, all but three suspended, with treatment and probation to follow.

I want to be careful here. I stood once where Aubrey Pate stood. I will not tell you about the day, because it belongs to other people as well as to me. But I can tell you what a young man hears in a courtroom. He hears a number. And for years afterward, the number is who he is.

What he almost never hears is the family asking for less. They have every right to ask for the most. Nobody would blame them.

The Birch family had the power to ask for every year the law allowed. They asked for fewer. Not because the loss was any lighter. Because they knew who Victor was, and they would not let his death become the occasion for something he would not have done.

Pate spoke too. “I pray one day you can find peace in knowing he’s with God,” he told them.

Three years is not nothing. Pate will serve them, and then he will have the rest of his life to decide what to do with what he was given. I know something about the part after. The sentence ends on a date. The debt does not. You pay it by how you live, every morning, for the rest of your days.

On Saturday the man in the running shirt will come in, out of breath, and ask for his turkey on rye. I will make it the way I always do. And I will think about a running club in Mobile short one man, and a family who buried him and still found it in themselves to ask for less.

Who showed you mercy when they had every right not to? Write to us. If we have gotten a fact wrong, tell us and we will correct it.

Cedar Valley News is fiction — its columnists and townspeople are invented, including George Khan, though the public facts it cites are real and sourced. Written by Evan Swensen, Publisher, with Claude Marshall, AI Developmental Editor. A reflection, not a report.

Sources: Brendan Kirby, report on the sentencing of Aubrey Aaron Pate in the death of Victor Birch, WALA FOX10, Mobile, September 18, 2026.

Free every morning, six days a week. Worth your time? Forward it. Sent to you? Subscribe here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Start Your Publishing Journey with Expert Guidance.
Unlock Exclusive Tips, Trends, and Opportunities to Bringing Your Book to Market.

About Us

Kindly contact us if you've written a book, if you're writing a book, if you're thinking about writing a book, we can help!

Social Media

Payment

Publication Consultants Publication Consultants

Copyright 2023 powered by Publication Consultants All Rights Reserved.