Verified and Unverified Reviews

The word “unverified” does not mean “invalid.” It means the reader found your book somewhere other than Amazon. Not a failure. A sign your book is traveling.

You check your Amazon page for the first time after your launch team has done its work. The reviews are there. Three in the first week. Your heart lifts. Then you notice the label beneath one of them.

“Unverified Purchase.”

Your stomach drops. You wonder if it counts. You wonder if Amazon is flagging it. You wonder if the reader did something wrong or if you did something wrong by sending them an advance copy.

Take a breath. The review counts. The reader did nothing wrong. Neither did you.

What the Labels Mean

“Verified Purchase” means Amazon can confirm the reviewer bought the book through their platform using their Amazon account. The purchase and the review are linked in Amazon’s system.

“Unverified” means the reviewer did not buy the book on Amazon — or Amazon cannot confirm they did. They may have received an advance copy. They may have bought it at a bookstore or a signing. They may have received it as a gift or borrowed it from a friend. Every one of these is a legitimate way to encounter a book, and every one of these readers is entitled to leave a review.

Unverified does not mean fake. It does not mean suspicious. It means the reader found the book somewhere other than Amazon’s checkout page.

Why Verified Reviews Carry More Weight

Amazon’s systems generally give verified reviews greater prominence and weight in how reviews are ranked and displayed. The reason is trust. A verified purchase means Amazon has proof the reviewer spent money on the book. A person who pays for something and takes the time to review it is, statistically, a more credible signal than someone who received a free copy.

This does not mean unverified reviews are worthless. They still count toward your total review number. They still appear on your page. They still influence browsers scanning for social proof. A book with fifteen reviews — ten verified and five unverified — looks far more credible than a book with zero.

What This Means for Authors

If you sent advance review copies before launch, the reviews from those readers will be unverified. This is expected. This is how the system works. The ARC is one of the most effective tools in publishing, and every review it produces is legitimate under Amazon’s rules. As a best practice, the reviewer should include a brief disclosure — “I received a free copy in exchange for an honest review” — though Amazon’s specific policies on disclosure evolve over time.

If a reader bought the book at your signing, at a bookstore, or from your website, their Amazon review will be unverified. This is a sign your book is reaching people through channels beyond Amazon — which is exactly what a healthy book does.

If you want to encourage verified reviews specifically, the simplest path is to ask readers who bought the book on Amazon to leave a review. Send them the direct link. The purchase and the review link automatically, and the verified badge appears.

What you must never do is manufacture reviews. Amazon’s detection systems look for patterns — bursts of five-star reviews from accounts with no history, reviewers who share addresses or payment methods with the author, review swaps between authors. Amazon has sued review brokers and terminated accounts. One dishonest review puts every honest review at risk.

Both Matter

The author who sees “unverified” on a review and panics is reacting to a label, not a reality. The reality is a human being read your book and cared enough to tell the world about it. Whether they bought it on Amazon or received it at a signing or found it on a friend’s shelf, they showed up. They wrote the review. They added their voice to the conversation around your book.

Verified reviews carry more algorithmic weight. Unverified reviews carry the same human weight.

Let the mix reflect the truth — your book is reaching people through every door available. A book with reviews from many sources is a book with a life beyond any single platform. And a life beyond any single platform is what every book deserves.

If this idea resonates with you, you will find the same philosophy throughout The Power of Authors by Evan and Lois Swensen, where every honest review is treated as a human connection, not a marketing metric.

The Power of Authors is available from Amazon or your favorite bookseller: http://evanswensen.com. If you’d like an autographed copy, you can order it here: http://bit.ly/4pgmzjM.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Start Your Publishing Journey with Expert Guidance.
Unlock Exclusive Tips, Trends, and Opportunities to Bringing Your Book to Market.

About Us

Kindly contact us if you've written a book, if you're writing a book, if you're thinking about writing a book, we can help!

Social Media

Payment

Publication Consultants Publication Consultants

Copyright 2023 powered by Publication Consultants All Rights Reserved.