Reviews Beyond Amazon
Amazon reviews tell readers your book has been read. Trade reviews tell librarians and booksellers your book has been evaluated.
When I first met Weston Fields, he looked every bit the Kodiak fisherman — rubber boots, suspenders, wool shirt. He was there to support his mother, who had written a book about ranching history on the island. She spoke first. He said almost nothing. When he finally did, it was to tell me — gently — he had already edited her manuscript.
I chuckled to myself. He didn’t look like any editor I’d ever met.
Turns out, I was the one who needed editing.
Weston was a scholar, a linguist, and a historian who spoke five languages fluently. He had interviewed every living figure associated with the Dead Sea Scrolls. He served as Executive Director of the Dead Sea Scrolls Foundation. More than once, as we worked on The Dead Sea Scrolls: A Full History, he paused mid-conversation to confirm a detail — not online, not from a book, but from a prince on his speed dial. Fluent Arabic, calm tone, quiet certainty. Then back to work.
I looked at rubber boots and made an assumption. I was wrong. First impressions do not always tell us what something is worth. Sometimes we need an informed second opinion.
A book faces the same challenge. Friends may love it. Amazon readers may praise it. But a librarian deciding which titles to acquire or a bookstore manager deciding which books to stock sometimes wants a different kind of opinion — an evaluation from someone whose job is to evaluate books.
Read and Evaluated
Amazon reviews give us the experience of readers. A stranger read the book, formed an opinion, and shared it. The value is social proof — evidence the book has been read and responded to by real people.
Trade reviews give industry professionals an independent critical assessment. A professional reviewer — trained, experienced, and writing to the standard of traditional publishing criticism — reads the book and evaluates its quality, effectiveness, and audience. The value is professional credibility — evidence the book has been examined by someone with no personal connection to the author.
Neither replaces the other. Neither guarantees sales. They serve different purposes and reach different audiences.
The Options
Several services offer professional reviews to independent authors. Among the most recognized are Kirkus Indie Reviews, Foreword’s Clarion Reviews, BlueInk Review, and BookLife by Publishers Weekly. Each charges a fee — typically several hundred dollars — and assigns a professional reviewer to read and evaluate the book.
A positive trade review opens doors Amazon reviews cannot reach. Libraries use trade reviews from recognized publications to guide acquisition decisions. A strong review quote can be added to the book’s Amazon listing through Author Central’s Editorial Reviews section, where the publication’s name carries weight beyond the words themselves. The review also becomes a permanent piece of the media kit — useful in pitches to podcast hosts, journalists, event coordinators, and bookstores.
Most paid review services allow the author to choose whether an unfavorable review is published, but the investment is made regardless of the outcome. The review may be critical. It may identify weaknesses the author did not see. This is part of its value — an honest evaluation is useful even when it is uncomfortable.
What Is This For?
Before spending several hundred dollars on a professional review, ask the same question we ask before writing anything at Publication Consultants: What is this for?
If the answer is “I want another five-star review,” a trade review is the wrong tool. Professional reviewers do not write endorsements. They write evaluations.
If the answer is “I want an independent critical assessment helping me approach librarians, booksellers, or media with credibility,” then investigate the options. Research the services. Compare their costs, timelines, and the audiences they reach. Choose the one serving your book’s specific goals.
If the answer is “My book’s audience is reached primarily through Amazon and direct sales,” the investment may serve the author better elsewhere — in advertising, in events, in building the email list.
I looked at Weston Fields and saw a fisherman. What I missed was a scholar who could telephone a prince to check a fact. The trade review exists because first impressions — even good ones — are not the only kind of evaluation worth having.
If this idea resonates with you, you will find the same philosophy throughout The Power of Authors by Evan and Lois Swensen, where every decision in the author’s journey begins with the question: What is this for?
The Power of Authors is available from Amazon or your favorite bookseller: http://evanswensen.com. If you’d like an autographed copy, you can order it here: http://bit.ly/4pgmzjM.
It is the summer of 1951. London is still pockmarked with bomb sites. Food is still rationed. Men who survived the Burma Railway, the North Atlantic convoys, the firebombing of cities have come home to a country worn to nothing by six years of war and five more of austerity. The war ended in 1945. The damage did not.
Robin Barefield lives in the wilderness on Kodiak Island, where she and her husband own a remote lodge. She wrote her first novel, Murder Over Kodiak, powered by a generator, miles from the nearest road. No MFA. No publishing connections. No high-speed internet.
A reader once walked into a bookstore and said, “I’m looking for a mystery set in Alaska.” The bookseller reached for a shelf and handed her a book.
The ceremony is the same every year. The names are the same. The readers change — grown children now where small children once stood, grandchildren where children once stood. The memorial pools fill the footprints of the towers. The water falls continuously.
Open a browser you do not normally use. Type your name. Hit search.
He had grown up in Bujumbura, the capital — the son of a French father and a Rwandan Tutsi mother. In 1994, the genocide in neighboring Rwanda killed between 500,000 and 800,000 people in one hundred days. Civil war followed in Burundi. His family left. He grew up in France.
The morning after. The folding tables are back in the garage. The leftover food is in the refrigerator. The unsold books are stacked on the dining room table. The banner is rolled up in the corner.
Lee came to the United States from Seoul at age three, with his mother and sister, to join his father, a psychiatrist who had immigrated earlier. He grew up in Westchester County, outside New York City. As a child, he often translated for his Korean-speaking mother. He stood between two languages for her, carrying her words into English and the world’s words back to her.
Monday morning. A bookstore manager sits down with forty-seven unread messages. She has an hour before the store opens. She is deciding which emails deserve her attention and which ones can wait.
The novelist Ella Camposanto has arrived in Sicily with her twelve-year-old daughter, Manuela. They are staying near the ruins where the narrator’s grandmother once worked on an archaeological dig. The summer is full of volcanic rumbles and sudden storms. The narrator’s mother is beginning to forget.
When I was publishing Alaska Outdoors magazine, the head of the journalism department at the University of Alaska sent me a submission. It was so poorly written, I took it for a joke. I answered it as a joke, only to learn the author was serious. He simply had such an inflated self-image; his writing read like a spoof. It was no spoof.
At 8:15 on the morning of August 6, 1945, Kiyoshi Tanimoto was on the outskirts of Hiroshima, unloading a handcart at a house in the suburb of Koi. He was two miles from the city center. He had slept poorly — the overnight air-raid warnings had kept him up — and he had risen early and set out with the cart.
Two books publish on the same Tuesday.
Among the nineteen longlisted novelists this year are writers who have been writing for a long time before this first novel existed.
You check your Amazon page for the first time after your launch team has done its work. The reviews are there. Three in the first week. Your heart lifts. Then you notice the label beneath one of them.
This is Publication Consultants’ motivation for constantly striving to assist authors sell and market their books. Author Campaign Method (ACM) of sales and marketing is Publication Consultants’ plan to accomplish this so that our authors’ books have a reasonable opportunity for success. We know the difference between motion and direction. ACM is direction! ACM is the process for authorpreneurs who are serious about bringing their books to market. ACM is a boon for them.
Release Party
Web Presence
Book Signings
Facebook Profile and Facebook Page
Active Social Media Participation
Ebook Cards
The Great Alaska Book Fair: October 8, 2016


Costco Book Signings
eBook Cards

Benjamin Franklin Award
Jim Misko Book Signing at Barnes and Noble
Cortex is for serious authors and will probably not be of interest to hobbyists. We recorded our Cortex training and information meeting. If you’re a serious author, and did not attend the meeting, and would like to review the training information, kindly let us know. Authors are required to have a Facebook author page to use Cortex.
Correction:
This is Publication Consultants’ motivation for constantly striving to assist authors sell and market their books. ACM is Publication Consultants’ plan to accomplish this so that our authors’ books have a reasonable opportunity for success. We know the difference between motion and direction. ACM is direction! ACM is the process for authors who are serious about bringing their books to market. ACM is a boon for serious authors, but a burden for hobbyist. We don’t recommend ACM for hobbyists.

We’re the only publisher we know of that provides authors with book signing opportunities. Book signing are appropriate for hobbyist and essential for serious authors. To schedule a book signing kindly go to our website, <
We hear authors complain about all the personal stuff on Facebook. Most of these complaints are because the author doesn’t understand the difference difference between a Facebook profile and a Facebook page. Simply put, a profile is for personal things for friends and family; a page is for business. If your book is just a hobby, then it’s fine to have only a Facebook profile and make your posts for friends and family; however, if you’re serious about your writing, and it’s a business with you, or you want it to be business, then you need a Facebook page as an author. It’s simple to tell if it’s a page or a profile. A profile shows how many friends and a page shows how many likes. Here’s a link <> to a straight forward description on how to set up your author Facebook page.



Mosquito Books has a new location in the Anchorage international airport and is available for signings with 21 days notice. Jim Misko had a signing there yesterday. His signing report included these words, “Had the best day ever at the airport . . ..”



The Lyin Kings: The Wannabe World Leaders
Time and Tide


ReadAlaska 2014
Readerlink and Book Signings
2014 Independent Publisher Book Awards Results

Bonnye Matthews Radio Interview
Rick Mystrom Radio Interview
When he published those overseas blogs as the book The Innocents Abroad, it would become a hit. But you couldn’t find it in bookstores.
More NetGalley
Mary Ann Poll
Bumppo
Computer Spell Checkers
Seven Things I Learned From a Foreign Email
2014 Spirit of Youth Awards
Book Signings


Blog Talk Radio
Publication Consultants Blog
Book Signings



Don and Lanna Langdok
Ron Walden
Book Signings Are Fun
Release Party Video
Erin’s book,
Heather’s book,
New Books
The Column Nobody Finished
Cedar Valley News — February 24, 2026
The Column Nobody Finished
By: George Khan
From the fictional town of Cedar Valley, where characters from Quiet Echo continue to respond to real-world events.
Read those two sentences again. The writing meant to connect a newspaper to its community was driving the community away.
The editors wrote it down in a memo: “Readers don’t want us to tell them how to think. They don’t believe we have the expertise to tell anyone what to think on most issues. They perceive us as having a biased agenda.”
The Des Moines Register cut its opinion pages to two days a week. Other Gannett papers dropped syndicated columns, eliminated editorial cartoons, and stopped endorsing candidates in federal races. An entire chain of American newspapers looked at the opinion page and decided it was broken beyond repair.
I fix broken things for a living. When a machine stops working, I do not throw it away. I open it up and find out why.
The opinion page did not break because people stopped caring about opinions. People care more than ever. Social media proved it. Everybody has something to say. The opinion page broke because the people writing it forgot to ask three questions before they started.
Why am I writing this? For whom? To what end?
I learned those questions from a book called The Power of Authors by Evan Swensen and Lois Swensen. The book is not about opinion columns. It is about writing with purpose — any writing, for any audience, in any form. But the principle fits an opinion page the way a carburetor fits an engine. Without it, nothing runs.
Here is what happens when a columnist skips those three questions. The piece opens with outrage. It assumes the reader already agrees. It builds no argument because it believes the conclusion is obvious. It acknowledges no other side because the other side is the enemy. It offers no solution because the point was never to solve anything. The point was to perform.
The reader finishes — if the reader finishes — feeling either validated or insulted. Neither one changed. Nobody moved. The writer spent eight hundred words and left the world exactly where it was.
Now watch what changes when the writer stops and answers those three questions first.
Why am I writing this? Not because I am angry. Because a nine-year-old is scrolling Instagram at midnight, and nobody at the company asked why. Because a young man nobody had heard of showed up at a gate with a shotgun and is now dead on the ground. The why has to be specific. One sentence. If you cannot say it in one sentence, you are not ready.
For whom? Not for everyone. For the mother checking her daughter’s phone at the kitchen table. For the neighbor who watches the headlines and feels something is wrong but cannot name it. Name one reader. Write to the person, not the crowd.
To what end? Not agreement. If the answer is “agree with me,” start over. The end is a question the reader carries into tomorrow. A conversation the reader starts instead of avoiding.
Answer those three questions honestly, and the piece changes shape before the first sentence is written. Outrage becomes evidence. Assumptions become arguments. The enemy becomes a fellow citizen who sees it differently and deserves to know why. The performance becomes a conversation.
The Des Moines Register’s opinion editor said his readers were tired of content aimed at “stoking divisions rather than offering solutions.” He is right. But the solution is not fewer opinion pages. The solution is better purpose behind the ones we publish.
Teresa said it yesterday. The hand holding the tool decides what gets built. A column is a tool. With purpose, it builds understanding. Without purpose, it just makes noise.
Lars Olson told me he can tell in thirty seconds whether a customer came in to fix something or to complain. The ones who came to fix walk straight to the aisle. The ones who came to complain stand at the counter and talk. Both are welcome. Only one leaves with the problem solved.
A good column walks straight to the aisle.
I am not a writer by trade. I fix engines. But I read the opinion page every morning with my coffee, and I can tell you the moment a columnist loses me. It is not when I disagree. I can read someone I disagree with all day if the argument is honest. I lose interest when the writer has no purpose beyond being right. When the column could have been written by anyone, about anything, on any day.
Cedar Valley’s opinion page works differently. Not because we are smarter. Because we ask three questions before we write. Every time. No exceptions.
Why am I writing this? For whom? To what end?
Try it. The next email you send. The next post you write. The next letter to the editor you draft at the kitchen table. Three questions. If you cannot answer all three in one sentence each, you are not ready to write.
And if you can, you will write something worth finishing.
This editorial is part of the fictional Cedar Valley News series. While the people and town are fictional, the national events they reflect on are real.
Want to know the full story behind Cedar Valley? Teresa, Caleb, Dan, and the community you’ve come to know in these editorials first came together in Quiet Echo. Discover how a small town found its way from fear to fellowship—one quiet act of courage at a time. Available on Amazon: https://bit.ly/3ME4nSs
Recent Posts
Feeding the Town Twice
Feeding the Town Twice
The People Who Wind the Clock
Reviews Beyond Amazon
The Town They Could Not Cancel
The Town They Could Not Cancel
The Man at the Bench
The Man You Blame for the Price
A Tonic for the Nation
We Regret the Error
A Fist You Cannot Open
How Readers Find Books Now
A Home It Has Never Seen
Something Big
Under One Roof
The Third Place
The Poem Found Its Readers
The Poem Found Its Readers
You Are the Meeting
The Warm Rock